Can we discriminate in fighting discrimination!?


I am dedicating this post to LGBT rights in Lebanon. It might resonate with human rights activism else where.

LGBT Protest in Sodeco square, Beirut - June 2009 against brutal use of violence by police

In the past decade, Beirut has got more international attention as the “Sin city” and “Provincetown” of the Middle East. More recently, Beirut appears to be gaining a world-wide reputation as a gay destination. This culminated with the announcement by IGLTA (International Gay and Lesbian Travel Association) of its 2010 Symposium being held in Beirut in Oct. 2010.

This drew a mixed reaction from the Lebanese LGBT community. Bekhsoos dedicated a whole issue criticizing and even mocking gay tourism in Beirut. Helem supported the event but the speech delivered did not shy from bluntly stating Helem’s skepticism about any benefit to the LGBT community from gay tourism. Raynbow Media Monitor’s report drew a variety of opposing reactions on the blog and on theLebanese LGBT Media Monitor.

IGLTA 2010 symposium in Beirut

An Ad by Aishti, Beirut in 2004 targeting LGBT consumers.

Reading through all different arguments, here is my impression on the conflict: A majority is probably not even aware of the controversy surrounding gay tourism and gay-friendly businesses. The few LGBT activists were divided. Sophisticated intellectuals call it neoliberalism and Western imperialism, the meaning of which I had to look up in a dictionary. Your everyday leftist will argue: “Do not use my pocket to enrich yours”. Others believe that LGBT-friendly business and gay tourism promote the LGBT cause. I believe the issue is too complex to be summed up in a rigid black or white opinion.

This issue resurfaced few days ago when Helem’s administrator, Hiba Abbani, wrote an article for Al-Akbar titled “LGBT rights: Down with Sectarianism“. The article opens with comments about IGLTA’s 2010 symposium and continues to talk about pink dollars, consumerism and ends with calling on LGBT people “to fight the market and not surrender to it.” Abbani’s article intimidated few activists especially that it can be easily misinterpreted as the official position of Helem. (Read Did Helem miss!? “ما موقف جمعية حلم من موقف “جمعية حلم by Raynbow Media Monitor)

The LGBT community in Lebanon is very diverse. It has the poor and rich, the leftist and right winged, professionals and artists, activists, slacktivists and pacifists, the LGBT rights fanatics and the all-inclusive human rights advocates, etc…

  1. Do we advocate for the rights of one LGBT group and not the other?
  2. In our fight to end discrimination, are we allowed to discriminate?
  3. Are we assuming that LGBT who are more financially grounded face less discrimination, coming out struggles, social marginalization and stigma as compared to less financially founded LGBT?
  4. Are less financially blessed LGBT more worth of our activism than more financially achieved?

As for LGBT-friendly venues, those have their list of prices available. By visiting, you are accepting their terms and the profit margin they chose. It is great If they donate, it is fine if they don’t. Helping the community should be applauded but not expected. Those venues are not more expensive than your mainstream homophobic business in Beirut. So which is more efficient, investing our time and effort in fighting LGBT-welcoming businesses or the plethora of homophobic places that have similar profit-driven tactics!?

I am all for social justice and for fighting classism, but let us not be hypocritical, if we are to start a campaign against inhumane practices by businesses let us not launch it only against LGBT-friendly ones.

LGBT supporters march within the Laique Pride. Beirut, 2010



Categories: Human Rights

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

3 replies

  1. Thank you for bringing this important issue to the attention of your readers. I just read the actual article on the Al-Akhbar site and left a comment in Arabic applauding the discourse that has been generated by Heba’s piece. It may not all be positive but it is my hope that healthy debate is one of the best ways to change people’s minds. It may take time but it is a step in the right direction.
    Ramzi

    Like

Trackbacks

  1. Gay bars and activists « G-AZZI
  2. Current debates on LGBT activism in Lebanon: between consumerism and inclusivity « Raynbow Media Monitor

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: